Brothers and Sisters, One and All is an Optional Honor Story Mission in Red Dead Redemption 2. This Walkthrough shows how to complete this Mission. Playing it is required for the missable Lending a Hand trophy.
Quest Giver: Brother Dorkins / Sister Calderón
Region: Saint Denis
Requirements: having finished Help a Brother Out
Brothers and Sisters, One and All Starting Location
Not too long after our first encounter with Brother Dorkins, we can meet him and Sister Calderón in front of a small church, teaching children how to read.
Unfortunately, one brat steals her crucifix and runs off.
For the Gold Medal, we need to get to the kid within 19 seconds. No problem. At the end of the street, turn left and then right, ignoring the man on the ground.
We will see that the boy was stopped by another man who was pickpocketed by the kid as well. Once you step in, both will walk off without any major trouble.
After an unfortunate run-in with a certain woman, we will be chased by the law.
Simply run to the end of the market and just as far as possible from the “crime-scene”.
When the heat has died off, we need to deliver the crucifix back to Sister Calderón, who is waiting in front of the large church.
There will be a few law-men patrolling – so you can’t approach her from the front entrance.
Head around the back of the church and walk along the left side to reach her and return her crucifix.
This concludes the “Brothers and Sisters, One and All” Story Missions in Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2). For all other Story Missions check out the full Red Dead Redemption 2 Missions Walkthrough.