No, No and Thrice, No is the 50th main story mission in Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2). This walkthrough will guide you through all objectives of No, No and Thrice, No Main Quest including all Gold Medals for 100% completion.
No, No and Thrice, No is unlocked after completing The Joys of Civilization.
Quest Giver: Mary-Beth
Gold Medal Requirements:
- Kill both of the Foreman boys yourself during the chase
- Complete with at least 90% accuracy
Starting Location: Shady Belle, Lemoyne
Talk to Mary-Beth
While having a nice chat with Mary-Beth, Susan Grimshaw will hurry in with dire news. Tilly has been taken by the Foremen Brothers, and you have to go save her!
Go to Radley’s House
Radley’s House is just outside of Rhodes. Get on the wagon and drive Ms. Grimshaw to the yellow objective area. She will stab the guard in the neck quietly, then take position next to the front door of the house. Kick down the front door.
- GOLD MEDAL: Complete with at least 90% accuracy
There will be one gunman in the kitchen to the left.
Kick down the second door to the right, and you’ll see a gunman standing over Tilly. Use Dead Eye to ensure that you don’t accidentally hit her.
Cut Tilly free. She tells you that there were more than what you’d already killed.
Going out the back door, you see some of Foreman’s boys mounting up and riding away. You leave Tilly with a repeater and hop on a horse with Ms. Grimshaw behind you.
Chase Down the Henchmen
- GOLD MEDAL: Kill both of the Foreman boys yourself during the chase
The key is that she will shoot anything that you get too close to, so use your Dead Eye to kill them before Ms. Grimshaw does. You have to kill the first two riders, because the gang leader needs to be taken alive.
Once they’re both dead, equip your lasso and chase after Anthony Foreman.
Rope him, get off your horse, hogtie him, then load him up. Ms. Grimshaw steals Foreman’s horse to head back ahead of you to check on Tilly. Bring Foreman back to the house for Tilly.
When you arrive, dump him on the ground for the women to look at. Don’t feel like you have to be too gentle about it either.
Tilly eventually leaves it up to you whether Foreman lives or dies. Choose depending on what morality you’re going for, and the mission will be complete.
This finishes No, No and Thrice, No main mission in Red Dead Redemption 2. Now the next quest A Fine Night of Debauchery starts.
Next Up: A Fine Night of Debauchery
For more Walkthroughs with all gold medals, check out the complete Red Dead Redemption 2 Story Walkthrough.